“That’s 3! TIME-OUT!”
I can hear it behind my closed bedroom door even with the humidifier running on high. It’s an hour past his bedtime and my 3.5 year old is pulling at every last nerve of our entire family.
I laugh because at that very moment I was contemplating whether or not there truly is any happiness in parenting. Not happiness in your children or your family, but in the actual act of parenting.
I honestly don’t think there is.
Now, the masses may gasp, turn their noses up at me and write me off as a horrible person who doesn’t love her children. But to those I say, you are not listening.
Loving your children and loving the act of parenting them are not one in the same.
I love my children.
I don’t like parenting them.
I recently read an article I found at the bottom of a pile on my desk. My mother sent it to me months ago, when I was neck-deep in worries that I would never snap out of my PPD. The article was entitled, “All Joy and No Fun: Why parents hate parenting“.
It is not the most uplifting of articles, but it touches on some serious notions about parenting and discusses studies that have been done on parenting and happiness.
Some of the findings were striking:
“Parents are more depressed than nonparents no matter what their circumstances – whether they’re single, married, whether they have one child or four; Mothers are less happy than fathers, single parents are less happy still, babies and toddlers are the hardest and each successive child produces diminishing returns; having children invariably reduces marital satisfaction…”
This article and these dire findings made me take a closer look at myself and the issues I have been struggling with as a mother. I love my kids, but I dread the day-to-day parenting.
Does this mean I don’t love my children? It sure feels like it, when you think back to your day and you can’t think of one enjoyable thing about it.
Are all my days like this? No, but to be honest, the majority are.
This leads me to think I am some horrible person, missing some maternal gene that all the other mothers in the world seem to possess.
Is this the case? No.
Even with all these studies, every researcher found that not a single parent regretted having children. Not one.
“The broad message is not that children make you less happy; it’s just that children don’t make you more happy.”
I think it comes down to how you define your happiness. I am not happy and fulfilled on a daily basis. Yet, my life is enriched and more meaningful by having my children and my husband.
I believe that I was wrong in believing that having children would somehow define me as a person. I truly believed that by having children I would be eternally happy, feel ultimately fulfilled and be the shiny goddess of motherhood.
I kid you not, I did.
So what a shock to have this vision of motherly bliss be broken apart by the reality of parenting.
One of my favorite quotes from the article that made me laugh out loud in agreement was from one of the author’s fellow psychologist and father of two:
“[Children] They’re a huge source of joy, but the turn every other source of joy to shit.”
I understand why my mother sent this to me. She knew I could relate, even if she couldn’t or not many I know could.
I can.
This journey of parenting and motherhood has not been what my little doe-eyed younger self envisioned. Call that girl naive or just hopeful. Call her what you want, but the mother she is today is not all that happy with her job as a parent.
However despite it all, I don’t regret it and I can’t imagine sending my kids off to be raised by someone else.
This is my job.
I chose this job.
I yearned for this job and at times, for brief moments, moments when I can hear my kids giggling together in their bedroom as they are waking up for the day, the squeals of delight I get when I return home from only a five-minute outing, the wonder I see in their eyes when they experience something for the first time, the sense of pride I can see all over their faces when they finally figure out how to climb to the top of the playground on their own; I get the wind knocked out of me with the amount of joy I feel as a parent.
It is in those rare moments that I am reminded of why I chose this difficult job.
I find peace in knowing that this is the hardest job I will ever have.
I find peace in knowing that I chose this job and do not regret one moment of it thus far.
I find peace in knowing that loving your children and loving the act of parenting them are not one in the same.
I hold on to those brief amazing moments of bliss, because they are what truly matter.
I hold on to them tightly because I know I did not have children to make me happy, I had children to bring meaning to my life and with that I am truly blessed and beyond happy.
“I don’t want to sit in time-out! NO! You are mean Daddy!”
The screaming gets louder and louder as he makes his way to the top step.
The bedroom door opens and my husband storms in. We catch each other’s eye and breath deeply together.










{ 27 comments… read them below or add one }
Twitter: mommyneedsvaca
November 11, 2010 at 11:05 am
You are SO RIGHT. They are not the same thing. I too thought that parenting was my calling and that I would LOVE doing it. LOVE staying home with my kids. LOVE doing art projects with them. LOVE it all…ummm, yeah. I don’t. I love my kids but parenting is not so fun. I couldn’t agree more with you!
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 11:07 am
Thanks mama. It is hard and people judge you for saying things out loud that they only think in their privately. HUGS!
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
Twitter: treerootandtwig
November 11, 2010 at 11:18 am
My arms are literally ACHING to give you a great big hug right now. YES YES YES, is what I have to say to this post. YES!!!! A thousand times, yes. If you were to put on paper all the things a mom has to deal with during the day – the defiance, the messes, the tears, the gross stuff, the mis-communications, etc etc etc – NO ONE in their right mind would take the job! I mean, really! You are so spot on – loving my children is different than loving the business of motherhood. And I am SO like you, I feel it my bones – I am not so happy on a daily basis – heck, I don’t even strive for happy anymore, I just strive for sane – but I am deeply happy and grateful for my blessings. I don’t think it’s a contradiction to say that, either. LOVE this post!
Stacey @ Tree, Root, and Twig recently posted..Road Rippers R-C Car Review
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:09 pm
Wow! Thanks so much mama! I know, can you believe we met so briefly and that was it. I think people just need to be real, honest and not worry about what other people think about them. I know I am a good mom, but right now, the daily baby and preschool stuff is not for me. It is hard and I am not ashamed to admit it.
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
More people need to be honest about feeling this way. There are tons of joys in parenting but there are also a lot crappy parts too and day to day it can be easy to get bogged down in the crap.
I never thought I’d be the mother that counted down to bed time and here I am, only 8 months in, doing it pretty much every night.
I love my kid and I REALLY love her when she’s sleeping!
Conflicted Mean Girl recently posted..To All The Girls I’ve Loved Before – Part 2
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:11 pm
Ha! Don’t feel bad mama. We all do that. It is hard to stay at home and do the same thing over and over and over again. I knew it would be hard, but just not this hard and in this way. Bedtime is hard especially because you are both exhausted from the day! Chin up lovey! I am hear for you!!!
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
“[Children] They’re a huge source of joy, but the turn every other source of joy to shit.” — That is laugh-out-loud true!
I’m a SAHM to three kids 6 and 4yo twins. Obviously, I love them. And I enjoy watching them grow and helping them learn. But the “parenting” part, yuck. Thanks for sharing.
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:15 pm
I can only imagine how much harder it is for you with 3 kids! Thanks for reading and commenting. It really means a lot to me.
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
I read this article, too and thought to myself, FINALLY! Someone gets it! All these tabloid mags with stories of celebrities’ babies “saving their lives” make me sick. Yes, the reality of parenting is not all joy but there are some wonderful moments – even if they are rare.
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:19 pm
Well, they have saved their lives and made them so happy because all they have to do is pose for pictures and pay the nannies. They get all the fun parts of parenting and not of the grunt we are talking about. Would you want it that way? I am not sure, it is hard for me to imagine.
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
I’m actually the happiest I’ve ever been, but that could just be the antidepressants for the PPD
. I wrote you a response over at my blog.
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:21 pm
That is awesome, so glad for you. I will have to check out your post! So happy to have this turning into a discussion with everyone! Thanks for participating.
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
I say the “happiest I’ve ever been” someone tongue-in-cheek as I just recently told some friends and blogged, “emotions are a luxury I can’t afford”. I think some of the happiness has come with facing long-enduring insecurities, and in all seriousness, the lexapro has been amazing for me.
Paige recently posted..Working Through Discipline
Amen! Mike and I just look at each other and say either verbally or non-verbally, “We are on the same team.”
Having children is easy but raising them is hard!
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:38 pm
So hard! Luckily our four are some of the cutest or we would really be in trouble!
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
I LOVE this! You actually made me cry while I was reading this and eating chocolate chip cookies… Never thought that was possible
Thanks for sharing a little piece of your wisdom with us. You wrote so eloquently something that most of us can agree with. Big hugs to you!
Autumn recently posted..Discovering Autumn
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 11, 2010 at 5:39 pm
Ha! Gosh, thank you! I am sorry to make you cry, but so happy to strike a chord with you! Hugs!
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
Twitter: evolvingmommy
November 12, 2010 at 12:36 am
I was just thinking about this exact topic tonight as my daughter chose to run circles around the couch instead of let me put her pajama top on her. I love her. More than anything. Honestly it isn’t all craft projects and cookie baking with smiles plastered on everyone’s faces. It’s a lot of “I said don’t touch that,” and “No. I said no. Didn’t you hear me say no twice just now?” and “Ugh and Mmph and screech are not words, I would love to hear what you have to say when you decide you want to use your words.”
Parenting is not fun. Motherhood can be fun. But Parenting? No.
Catherine recently posted..Counting with Pumpkin Seeds
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 12, 2010 at 1:58 pm
Parenting, No, Motherhood, Yes. Love it. Why does it have to be so hard! HA!
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
Twitter: laurenacarlton
November 12, 2010 at 2:28 am
BEST BLOG POST EVER. I agree a million percent.
This is one of my fave posts from you ever, Sue! Thanks for making me feel normal. I think my expectations were too in the cloud– having a perfect kid that will sleep til 8 and never test boundaries because I’ll raise him right. HA! I’ve since realized that not everything in life is within our control. Kids will be kids. Parenting them is dang hard but I have now ACCEPTED that this IS parenting. It’s not gonna be perfect but I’ll take it as it comes and cherish the good things about it.
Again, great post!
Melissa {adventuroo} recently posted..Friday Favorites- Photo Tips- Bullying- Activity Guide and More!
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 12, 2010 at 11:05 pm
Thank you Mel! So sweet! I just am in a place in my life where I am conflicted and cannont take any bullshit. Ya know?
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
This I believe is the best blog you’ve ever written. Very well said and probably the private thoughts of many. Now you can look at the gray hair and know that we earned every one of them. Who ever thought that the labor pains at birth would just be the beginning of it? The result of your committed efforts though will always shine through. I think it’s only the lazy parents who might ever say that it’s easy. So don’t blink your eyes too long. One day too soon you’ll realize that they’re all grown up. Those will also be the days that you’ll realize a job well done.
Hugs to you always ♥
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 13, 2010 at 11:39 am
Thanks Aunt Betty! SO sweet! I know I will miss these days…one day. So I try my hardest to hold on to the good times. Like right this second…Barrett is kissing her baby doll, then kissing me and saying “Mama.” Ahhhhh so cute.
Sue Robinson recently posted..Happiness in Parenting
When i read this post just i remember another post which i read earlier, Its something about the signs of a frustrated mother, it goes like this “Your children tell you that you said “yes” and you don’t even remember the question.”
Nice post Sue…:)
James
James Fulton recently posted..Rimadyl For Dogs Review
Twitter: MotherhoodnMe
November 19, 2010 at 1:39 pm
I probably do that with my kids too, sad right. I also have become that mom can totally tuned out her children screaming public and carry on a conversation while people stare at her like she is a freak. Nice right? Do you have kids?
Sue Robinson recently posted..Wordless Wednesday- Good Times at the Zoo
Sue, that’s a good one. actually made me laugh.
BTW My Daughter’s name is Danni, We love her very much and we feel blessed to have her as our daughter.
James
James Fulton recently posted..Adequan Canine Review